San Jose Earthquakes vs. St. Louis City SC

Saturday’s night at PayPal Park was a bitter one for San Jose. In a 3–1 defeat to St. Louis City SC, the Quakes were exposed in spells—especially early—and never fully recovered.


St. Louis struck early and struck decisively. Brendan McSorley opened his MLS account in the 10th minute, and added a header just before half to make it 3–1 going into the break. Marcel Hartel’s curling strike earlier had already marked City’s intent as brutally efficient.


San Jose showed flashes—Cristian “Chicho” Arango answered with a penalty in the 31st minute—but the Quakes couldn’t sustain momentum. Their dominance in possession and volume of shots counted for little when the rhythm was broken and defensive lapses crept in.


The loss deepens the questions facing Bruce Arena’s side. When structural issues take hold—especially at the back—no amount of attacking pressure can paper over the cracks. In Leagues of tight margins, that’s lethal.

For St. Louis, this was more than a road win—it was growth in real time. A first MLS brace for McSorley, a composed team performance, and a statement that they belong, even in hostile environs.


Ultimately, this 3–1 result was a reminder: in MLS, the strongest teams don’t just threaten—they punish. San Jose will regroup, but the night will sting when the tape is watched.